Wednesday, April 08, 2009

Non-minimal production cost production locations better for planet than minimal production cost production locations--an example

Roughly speaking, traditionally the majority opinion amongst economists has been, that buying product X, for price P1 from vendor V1, when an equivalent quantity and quality of product X can be bought from vendor v2 for price P2, when price p1 is higher than price P2, automatically damages the world economy, through the negative effect it exerts on the world's net income vs prices equation.

This is incorrect. the negative impact on the world's income vs prices equation, can be more than compensated for by factors related to how the money paid to the vendor circulates after the vendor is paid.

Imagine two planets, planets Alpha and Beta. Nation A is a nation on planet Alpha, and nation B is a nation on planet Beta. Nation A and nation B are identical twins as are planets Alpha and Beta.

Nation A on planet Alpha, faces higher non-wages production costs and higher wage costs when it comes to producing product Sigma, compared to other nations on planet Alpha. This nation A imports the product Sigma it consumes.

Nation B on planet Beta, like nation A on planet Alpha, faces higher non-wages production costs and higher wage costs when it comes to producing product Sigma, compared to other nations on planet Beta. Nation B, unlike nation A on Alpha, nevertheless chooses to produce the product Sigma that it consumes in its own territory, domestically, paying higher prices for product sigma compared to what would be the case if it imported product sigma.

Earth's simple minded economists who regurgitate what they have failed to digest (understand), will be surprised to learn, that nation B's domestic production approach, contributed more to nation B than Nation A's importing approach contributed to nation A; and nation B's domestic production approach, contributed more to the economy of it's planet Beta, compared to the positive impact of nation A's importing approach on the planet it is on, planet Alpha.

There are several reasons for the surprising outcome.

Reduction of costs in money time and human energy required for production per unit, is the major engine of actual (as opposed to illusionary) world economic growth.

Nations facing high production costs and high labor costs can by nature, tend to be more inclined to put resources into attempts to reduce non-wage production costs, compared to nations that enjoy low production costs and low labor costs. Nations featuring high wages can tend to have more money available to spend on goods and services that increase productivity.

After Nation B's management and workers were paid for producing product Sigma, as the money spent and invested by nation B's management and workers passed from person to person through financial transactions, a high percentage of the transactions involved persons purchasing goods and services that increased their productivity, their nation's productivity, and their planet's productivity (productivity per dollar paid and per hour worked).

An example of this was investments that increased productivity in terms of production of product Sigma in nation B.

By way of contrast, on planet Alpha, nation A imported product Sigma because imports of product Sigma were cheaper than domestic production of product Sigma.

The workers and management in nation D, the nation that nation A imported the product Sigma from, started chain reactions that damaged the productivity of the world, when they spent and invested the money that they received as payment for the product Sigma that they exported to planet A.

The people that nation D workers and management bought things from, took the money that they got, and spent it on things that damaged their own productivity as individuals, damaged the productivity of their nation, and damaged the productivity of their planet that they shared with nation A, planet Alpha.

Then those who sold the things that damaged productivity to the workers and management in nation D who got money from nation A for the product sigma, took the money they got for selling the things that damage productivity, and used it to buy more things that damage productivity, on and on it went like that.

Looking at the impact nation A's import-oriented approach had on nation A, compared to the impact nation B's self-sufficient approach had on nation B, nation A's citizens were reduced, through lack of circulation of money leading to poverty, to a state wherein from the productivity per dollar paid and also the productivity per hour worked perspectives, the input-output equations for them as individuals became non-optimal.

Meaning, if they got paid X amount, their productivity per dollar paid would have been greater; but they got paid less than X amount, because of the lack of domestic circulation of money due to the nation A's imports-oriented policy.

If they got paid Y amount, their productivity per hour worked would have been greater, and their productivity per hour spent studying would have been greater; but they got paid less than Y amount, due to the lack of money flowing through the nation A, due to nation A's imports-oriented policy.

By way of contrast in nation B on planet Beta, the reverse held true. In nation B on planet Beta: the citizens of planet Beta were paid not less than the amount at which their productivity per dollar paid was the greatest; rather, they were paid the amount at which their productivity per dollar paid was the greatest, because there was money circulating through the economy of nation B in sufficient quantity so as to allow for such to occur.

In nation B, workers were paid the amount at which their productivity per hour spent working or studying was the greatest, as opposed to a lesser amount, again due to the domestic circulation of money in nation B created through nation B's self-sufficient imports-independent, import-alternatives approach.

Thus in the end, planet B on planet Beta, which resorted to domestic production of product B, through its self-reliance, created a positive impact on planet Beta's economy, which outweighed the negative impact on planet Beta's economy, caused by the adverse impact on the planetary income vs prices ration equation.

Planet A on planet Alpha, by way of contrast, loving low prices, imported product sigma instead of producing product sigma domestically, and thereby created a negative impact on planet Alpha's economy; this negative impact outweighed the advantage produced for planet Alpha's income vs prices ratio equation, which derived from nation A choosing to utilize the lowest price source of product sigma.

@2009 David Virgil Hobbs

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

Non-minimal production-cost-locations shunned, a tale of global net loss

Imagine an ideal production location, location A, which is ideal for the purposes of producing product B, and selling product B to consumer group C, which is located at location D. Population group E is used to produce the product B at location A. Aside from wages, the production costs for product B at location A are the lowest in the world.

For various reasons, location A is ideal for producing product B and selling it to population C.

Group E, which is employed in the production of product B at location A, is both mentally and physically speaking, relative to other population groups, superior in terms of the abilities required to produce product B.

The river running through location A, the nature of the land at location A, the sunshine and wind conditions at location A, are such that location A is a superior location for the production of product B.

Location A is ideally situated in terms of transportation of product B that is produced at location A from location A to location D for sale to population C.

By way of contrast, imagine another location, location XA, which also produces product B, and sells product B to population XC, which is located at location XD; population XE is used to produce product B at location XE. Production costs aside from wages at location XA, are amongst the highest in the world.

Group XE, which is employed in the production of product B at location XA, is both mentally and physically speaking, inferior in terms of the abilities required to produce product B; this contrasts with the superior abilities of group E producing product B at location A.

The nature of the land, bodies of water, sunshine, and wind at location XA, are such that location XA is inferior to, and more expensive than (aside from wage costs) location A when it comes to the production of product B.

Location XA is inferior to location A when it comes to efficient transportation of product B to location D for sale to population C.

Historical Aside re Locations A and XA

For many decades, both location A and also location XA, produced product B, even though the production cost of product B was higher in the naturally gifted location A, due to higher wages being paid to the workers.

The natural trade barrier which was the high cost of transportation of good B, stimulated the production of product B in location A, a location where production costs aside from wage costs, were lower.

In the early stages of the production of product B at location A, looking at production costs aside from wages, the production costs for product B were higher than the production costs aside from wages for product B at location XA.
In the early stage, if transportation costs for product B were as low as they are today and free trade had been in effect, product B would never have been produced at location A.

Nevertheless, the peoples around location A persevered. The previously ignorant and habitually mentally lazy population E was trained; as a result, population E became able to utilize its superior abilities, to produce product B in high quantity at high quality. The leaders at location A realized that superior ability if not combined with adequate training can produce inferior performance.

The people of location A at first were incompetent in terms of exploitation of the natural resources around location A for the production of product B. But gradually, they became expert in terms of the exploitation of the natural resources for the purpose of the production of product B.

At first the location A people were foolish in terms of exploitation of the natural wind, land, water, and solar resources they were blessed with, for the purpose of transporting product B from production point A to sale point D where it was sold to customers C. But gradually, they learned to harness the wind, sun, water, and land for the purpose of transportation of product B.

Thus in the presence of the natural trade barrier which was the high transportation costs of product B, the production of product B developed in location A, whereas if the natural trade barrier that is high cost of transportation of product B had not existed, product B would never have been made in location A.

Location A improved and developed so that whereas previously aside from cost of wages it had been a more expensive place to produce product B in, it became, aside from wages, a less expensive place to produce product B in.

End Historical Aside

Then, a problem developed when technological advances in the art of transporting product B over thousands of miles, eradicated the natural trade barrier that had allowed location A to continue producing product B, even though production costs were higher at location A compared to location XA, due to high wages at location A (despite the fact that aside from wages production cost was lower at location A).

Due to the wage differential, production of product B at location A came to an end, and location XA became the only location at which product B was produced; this despite the fact that aside from wage differential--location XA was in every way a more expensive place to produce product B; and location XA was in terms of transportation cost in an inferior position compared to location A.

As a result of the shift of production of product B from location A to location XA, and as a result of the eradication of the natural trade barrier of high transportaion costs for product B through technological advances, the world experienced a general negative impact of the technological-progress-disrupts-nature type.

The world experienced negative impact, because whereas previously the natural advantages for production of good B which had developed in location A had been taken advantage of by the world, after the end of production of product B in location A, the world became a world which no longer took advantage of the natural advantages for production of product B that existed in location A.

The world experiences a negative impact in that whereas previously it did not expend resources shipping product B long distances (an unnecessary activity), now it expended considerable resources shipping product B long distances.

The reduction in wages paid to the producers of product B, resulted in price reductions for product B, which were balanced by a reduction in spending by the workers who previously made product B in location A.

Thus the world experienced negative impact, because a negative impact, plus a second negative impact, combined with two things that cancel each other out, is in the end, two negative impacts plus zero.

Other details of the not-so-happy ending of this tale (in brief):

World production and consumption of product B, a clean environment-friendly, fully bio-degradeable organic natural re-cyclable product, declined from 20 million tons per year which was the case when product B was produced in location A and location XA, to only 15 million tons per year which became the case when product B was produced in location XA alone;

Everywhere, all over the earth, there ensued a chilling effect that retarded progress in the art of decreasing costs of production in locations featuring non-minimal production costs, and a slowdown in technological progress;

All over the world, the abilities of people with talent in terms of the production of various products went unutilized, because the products were no longer made in lots of different places;

Ecological problems that naturally follow when a given thing predominates in a given eco-system arose, because whereas previously a given place produced lots of different things, the reduction in transportation costs produced by man's technological advance, created a situation where every place produced only one thing;

Places that used to rotate crops switched from crop rotation to growing only one crop, the result being soil depletion;

Unnecessary transportation costs increased because whereas previously a thing was produced in many places, the new situation was the the thing being produced in only a few places;

and there were yet more negative effects not now described.

@2009 David Virgil Hobbs

Labels: , , ,

SM
GA
SC